Challenges in High-Fidelity Implicit Block-Based Numerical Simulation of Dynamic Out-of-Plane Two-Way Bending in Unreinforced Brick Masonry Walls

This study deals with the high-fidelity block-based finite element simulation of dynamic out-of-plane (OOP) responses of unreinforced masonry (URM) walls, explicitly focusing on two-way bending behaviors under seismic loads, which is a common critical failure mode in real-world masonry structures. While experimental shake-table tests provide valuable insights into these behaviors, their high costs, complexity, and limited scalability highlight the need for advanced numerical modeling approaches. A state-of-the-art block-based finite element modeling strategy that conceives masonry as an assemblage of 3D damaging blocks interacting via contact-based cohesive-frictional zero-thickness interfaces, previously proposed for simulating cyclic quasi-static and dynamic one-way bending tests, is here extended for the first time to the simulation of incremental dynamic shake-table tests on OOP two-way spanning URM full-scale walls, subjected to a sequence of dynamic loads. The numerical models track the reference experimental behaviors with high accuracy in terms of collapse onset, failure mechanism, experienced acceleration and displacements, and hysteretic response. The effects of variations in mechanical properties, boundary conditions, and damping on the dynamic response are explored in a sensitivity study. The results indicate that slight changes in these parameters can lead to considerable differences in outcomes. This highlights the chaotic nature of the dynamic response of masonry walls, especially in near-collapse conditions, which makes probabilistic approaches more suitable for predicting masonry OOP dynamics. The proposed numerical methodology appears compatible with statistical frameworks, given the limited costs with respect to experimental tests, and it extends knowledge beyond physical experiments.