Corrigendum to “Molecular simulation of the vapor-liquid equilibria of xylene mixtures: Force field performance, and Wolf vs. Ewald for electrostatic Interactions” (Fluid Phase Equilibria (2019) 485 (239–247), (S037838121830503X), (10.1016/j.fluid.2018.12.006))

Sebastián Caro-Ortiz, Remco Hens, Erik Zuidema, Marcello Rigutto, David Dubbeldam, Thijs J.H. Vlugt

Research output: Contribution to journalComment/Letter to the editorScientificpeer-review

1 Citation (Scopus)

Abstract

Vapor-liquid equilibria of xylenes were computed using Monte Carlo simulations in the Gibbs ensemble. For binary mixtures, the predicted composition of the liquid phase is in agreement with experiments. The computed vapor phase densities of each isomer showed an effect on the predicted composition of the vapor phase of the mixture. Unfortunately, the Monte Carlo code used to calculate the vapor-liquid equilibrium contained an error in the acceptance rule for molecule transfer in multi-component mixtures. The Continuous Fractional Component (CFCMC) [1–3] algorithm in the Gibbs ensemble adds an extra molecule -the fractional molecule-per molecule type. In the CFCMC algorithm, trial moves are attempted to transform a fractional molecule of type a in box i to a whole molecule and, simultaneously, transform a molecule of type a in box j [Formula presented] i to a fractional molecule. These trial moves should be accepted according to Ref. [1]: [Formula presented] where [Formula presented] is the number of molecules of type a in box j, [Formula presented] is the number of molecules of type a in box i, and [Formula presented] is the energy difference between the old and the new configuration. Unfortunately, what was implemented (incorrectly) in the computer code is: [Formula presented] where [Formula presented] and [Formula presented] are the total number of molecules of all types in box i and j, respectively, and not only of type a. For the simulation of a single component, [Formula presented] and [Formula presented]. Therefore, the mistake in the acceptance rule only affects the simulations that include more than one component. As such, Figs. 1, Fig. 2, Fig. 3, Fig. 4, and Table 1 of the article are not affected by this error. This error was hard to detect for xylene isomers, as the boiling point of these isomers are close, and therefore [Formula presented] is close to [Formula presented]. The corrected code has been tested to yield the same results as the RASPA software [4,5] for various multi-component systems. The phase composition diagram using the correct code is shown in Fig. 5. The observations based on the incorrect results remain. The composition of the liquid phase is not affected by the choice of force field or method for electrostatic interactions. For all the force fields, the correct vapor phase composition calculated with the Ewald and the Wolf methods are closer than in the incorrect simulations. In the incorrect results, the largest difference between vapor phase composition calculated with the Wolf and the Ewald method was 0.089 [mol/mol]. In the correct results, this difference is reduced to 0.067 [mol/mol]. [Figure presented] The predicted composition of the liquid phase is in excellent agreement with the experimental data. The correct simulations of the vapor phase compositions are closer to the experimental data than the incorrect simulations. The simulations with the incorrect acceptance rules showed an azeotrope behaviour that is not present in the correct simulations of the phase compositions. [Figure presented] The phase composition of the binary mixture and the excess chemical potential are not related. This is consistent with the observations from the incorrect simulations. [Formula presented] The predicted composition of the liquid phase is in excellent agreement with the experimental data. The correct simulations of the vapor phase compositions are closer to the experimental data than the incorrect simulations. The simulations with the incorrect acceptance rules showed an azeotrope behaviour that is not present in the correct simulations. [Figure presented]

Original languageEnglish
Article number112370
Number of pages3
JournalFluid Phase Equilibria
Volume506
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2020

Fingerprint Dive into the research topics of 'Corrigendum to “Molecular simulation of the vapor-liquid equilibria of xylene mixtures: Force field performance, and Wolf vs. Ewald for electrostatic Interactions” (Fluid Phase Equilibria (2019) 485 (239–247), (S037838121830503X), (10.1016/j.fluid.2018.12.006))'. Together they form a unique fingerprint.

  • Research Output

    • 1 Citations
    • 1 Article

    Molecular simulation of the vapor-liquid equilibria of xylene mixtures: Force field performance, and Wolf vs. Ewald for electrostatic interactions

    Caro-Ortiz, S., Hens, R., Zuidema, E., Rigutto, M., Dubbeldam, D. & Vlugt, T. J. H., 2019, In : Fluid Phase Equilibria. 485, p. 239-247

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticleScientificpeer-review

  • 3 Citations (Scopus)

    Cite this