Deformation and strain limits for IPB-loaded high strength steel CHS joints

In this study, existing deformation limits are first re-examined to investigate if they can be rationally extended to high strength steel circular hollow section (CHS) joints that are subjected to in-plane bending (IPB) moment. It is pointed out that existing deformation limits, which have been developed and validated primarily for mild steel joints, need to be modified when high strength steels are involved. By noting that the ductility of IPB-loaded joints can be significantly reduced with the use of high strength steel, a new deformation limit is proposed which allows less deformation to less ductile high strength steel joints. The deformation limit, proposed in terms of joint rotation angle, is validated both numerically and experimentally. In addition, a recently proposed strain limit criterion is also discussed. To provide a guide for obtaining converged strain from finite element (FE) analysis, mesh sensitivity study is comprehensively conducted. It is shown that the element size required for the convergence of strain is substantially smaller than that required for obtaining satisfactory global response such as joint load-deformation relationship. By applying a systematic FE modeling strategy, numerical investigation is made to check the feasibility of the 5% strain limit criterion which has recently been advocated by the revised draft of ISO 14346. While the limiting principal strain of 5% is shown to be reasonable for CHS-to-CHS joints loaded by IPB, for longitudinal branch plate-to-CHS joints, a lower limiting strain appears more appropriate.