From fluid milk to milk powder: Energy use and energy efficiency in the European dairy industry

In this paper, we conduct a cross-country analysis of energy consumption and energy efficiency for the dairy industry in four European countries. Changes in energy efficiency were monitored in two different ways. One way is to look at the energy use by tonne of milk processed by dairies (EE I_{p 1}). Another way is by comparing the actual energy use with the energy that would have been used if no changes in energy efficiency would have taken place (EE I_{p 2}). A characteristic of EE I_{p 2} is that it corrects for differences in product mix among countries and in time. We found that changes in production mix are important in three of the four countries studied and that EE I_{p 2} should be preferred when comparing levels of energy efficiency among countries or when there are significant changes in product mix. Once changes in product mix have been taken into account, our results show that France, Germany, the Netherlands and the United Kingdom have reduced their values in EE I_{p 2}, respectively by -0.4%, -2.1%, -1.2% and -3.8% per annum. The results also show that the British, German and Dutch dairy industries have converged towards similar (lower) values in their energy efficiency indicators and that the French dairy industry would save 30% if were to converge to similar values of EE I_p as the ones obtained for Germany or the United Kingdom.