TY - JOUR
T1 - Leveraging organic acids in bipolar membrane electrodialysis (BPMED) can enhance ammonia recovery from scrubber effluents
AU - Mutahi, Gladys
AU - van Lier, Jules B.
AU - Spanjers, Henri
PY - 2024
Y1 - 2024
N2 - While air stripping combined with acid scrubbing remains a competitive technology for the removal and recovery of ammonia from wastewater streams, its use of strong acids is concerning. Organic acids offer promising alternatives to strong acids like sulphuric acid, but their application remains limited due to high cost. This study proposes an integration of air stripping and organic acid scrubbing with bipolar membrane electrodialysis (BPMED) to regenerate the organic acids. We compared the energy consumption and current efficiency of BPMED in recovering dissolved ammonia and regenerating sulphuric, citric, and maleic acids from synthetic scrubber effluents. Current efficiency was lower when regenerating sulphuric acid (22 %) compared to citric (47 %) and maleic acid (37 %), attributable to the competitive proton transport over ammonium across the cation exchange membrane. Organic salts functioned as buffers, reducing the concentration of free protons, resulting in higher ammonium removal efficiencies with citrate (75 %) and malate (68 %), compared to sulphate (29 %). Consequently, the energy consumption of the BPMED decreased by 54 % and 35 % while regenerating citric and maleic acids, respectively, compared to sulfuric acid. Membrane characterisation experiments showed that the electrical conductivity ranking, ammonium citrate > ammonium malate > ammonium sulphate, was mirrored by the energy consumption (kWh/kg-N recovered) ranking, ammonium sulphate (15.6) < ammonium malate (10.2) < ammonium citrate (7.2), while the permselectivity ranking, ammonium sulphate > ammonium citrate > ammonium malate, aligned with calculated charge densities. This work demonstrates the potential of combining organic acid scrubbers with BPMED for ammonium recovery from wastewater effluents with minimum chemical input.
AB - While air stripping combined with acid scrubbing remains a competitive technology for the removal and recovery of ammonia from wastewater streams, its use of strong acids is concerning. Organic acids offer promising alternatives to strong acids like sulphuric acid, but their application remains limited due to high cost. This study proposes an integration of air stripping and organic acid scrubbing with bipolar membrane electrodialysis (BPMED) to regenerate the organic acids. We compared the energy consumption and current efficiency of BPMED in recovering dissolved ammonia and regenerating sulphuric, citric, and maleic acids from synthetic scrubber effluents. Current efficiency was lower when regenerating sulphuric acid (22 %) compared to citric (47 %) and maleic acid (37 %), attributable to the competitive proton transport over ammonium across the cation exchange membrane. Organic salts functioned as buffers, reducing the concentration of free protons, resulting in higher ammonium removal efficiencies with citrate (75 %) and malate (68 %), compared to sulphate (29 %). Consequently, the energy consumption of the BPMED decreased by 54 % and 35 % while regenerating citric and maleic acids, respectively, compared to sulfuric acid. Membrane characterisation experiments showed that the electrical conductivity ranking, ammonium citrate > ammonium malate > ammonium sulphate, was mirrored by the energy consumption (kWh/kg-N recovered) ranking, ammonium sulphate (15.6) < ammonium malate (10.2) < ammonium citrate (7.2), while the permselectivity ranking, ammonium sulphate > ammonium citrate > ammonium malate, aligned with calculated charge densities. This work demonstrates the potential of combining organic acid scrubbers with BPMED for ammonium recovery from wastewater effluents with minimum chemical input.
KW - Ammonia recovery
KW - Bipolar membrane electrodialysis
KW - Membrane electrical conductivity
KW - Organic acid regeneration
KW - Permselectivity
KW - Scrubber effluents
UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85201686416&partnerID=8YFLogxK
U2 - 10.1016/j.watres.2024.122296
DO - 10.1016/j.watres.2024.122296
M3 - Article
AN - SCOPUS:85201686416
SN - 0043-1354
VL - 265
JO - Water Research
JF - Water Research
M1 - 122296
ER -