Retraction Note: Quantized Majorana conductance (Nature, (2018), 556, 7699, (74-79), 10.1038/nature26142)

Hao Zhang, Chun Xiao Liu, Sasa Gazibegovic, Di Xu, Guanzhong Wang, Nick van Loo, Jouri D.S. Bommer, Michiel W.A. de Moor, Diana Car, Roy L.M. Op het Veld, Sebastian Koelling, Marcel A. Verheijen, Joon Sue Lee, Erik P.A.M. Bakkers, Leo P. Kouwenhoven

Research output: Contribution to journalComment/Letter to the editorScientificpeer-review

Abstract

In this Letter, we reported electrical measurements and numerical simulations of hybrid superconducting–semiconducting nanowires in a magnetic field. We reported plateaus in the conductance at 2e2/h, which we interpreted as evidence for the presence of Majorana zero-modes. However, several inconsistencies were pointed out by Sergey Frolov and Vincent Mourik between the raw measurement data that was made available to them and the figures that were published in the paper. We therefore re-analysed all the existing raw data for our original measurements and rebuilt the original experimental set-up for a re-calibration of the conductance values. We established that the data in two of the figures (Fig. 2a and Extended Data Fig. 4b) had been unnecessarily corrected for charge jumps (corrections that were not mentioned explicitly in the paper), and that one of the figure axes was mislabelled (Fig. 4b). The new conductance calibration shifted the plateau values by 8 per cent, above 2e2/h, which affects all the figures1. When the data are replotted over the full parameter range, including ranges that were not made available earlier, points are outside the 2-sigma error bars. We can therefore no longer claim the observation of a quantized Majorana conductance, and wish to retract this Letter. After informing Nature of this decision, Nature issued an Editorial Expression of Concern2 and initiated the retraction process. In ref. 1 we provide all the raw data underlying the published figures as well as the unpublished datasets. Ref. 1 also contains the analysis methods and a side-by-side comparison between the original and the corrected figures. In ref. 3 we provide a new manuscript with corrected and extended datasets, discussed in the context of new insights on zero-energy states in systems with inhomogeneous potentials and disorder. We thank Piet Brouwer, Klaus Ensslin, David Goldhaber-Gordon and Patrick Lee for the expert evaluation report available via ref. 1. We also thank Michael Wimmer and Bernard van Heck for their help with the analyses. We apologize to the community for insufficient scientific rigour in our original manuscript.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)E30
JournalNature
Volume591
Issue number7851
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 25 Mar 2021

Fingerprint Dive into the research topics of 'Retraction Note: Quantized Majorana conductance (Nature, (2018), 556, 7699, (74-79), 10.1038/nature26142)'. Together they form a unique fingerprint.

Cite this