How to conduct more systematic reviews of agent-based models and foster theory development: Taking stock and looking ahead

Sebastian Achter, Melania Borit, Clémentine Cottineau*, Matthias Meyer, J. Gareth Polhill, Viktoriia Radchuk

*Corresponding author for this work

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleScientificpeer-review

3 Citations (Scopus)
123 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

Agent-based models (ABMs) are increasingly utilized in ecology and related fields, yet concerns persist regarding the lack of consideration for lessons learned from previous models. This study explores the potential of systematically conducted ABM reviews to contribute to cumulative science and theory development by synthesizing individual ABM findings more effectively. We are conducting a meta-review of ABM reviews to assess current practices, compare them to systematic literature review (SLR) literature recommendations, and evaluate their engagement with theory and theory development. Our analysis of the ecology and social science sample reveals that many reviews are not conducted systematically and lack transparency. The analysis step of SLRs holds significant potential to advance theory development. Reviews primarily focus on model design, while other avenues of theory development receive less attention. Our findings suggest ways to improve current practices and may guide future ABM reviews via benchmarks for methodological decisions and dimensions for advancing theory development.
Original languageEnglish
Article number105867
JournalEnvironmental Modelling & Software
Volume173
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2024

Funding

We thank Johannes Marold and Katarina Frey for their support with the processing of data and the creation of illustrations. Furthermore, we thank Andreas Flache and Flaminio Squazzoni for their inspiration during the earlier stages of the project. For the same reason and her role as a friendly reviewer, we also want to thank Birgit Müller and Nanda Wijermans. Lastly, we thank the Volkswagen foundation for hosting and financially supporting three symposia in the context of which this paper was written. A link to the project, including all data, analysis steps, and program code, can be found on GitHub.

Borit acknowledges funding from the Research Council of Norway (project references AFO-JIGG 302635 and FUTURES4Fish 325814). Cottineau acknowledges funding from the European Research Council (reference: Starting Grant 101039455 / SEGUE). Polhill acknowledges funding from the Scottish Government Rural and Environment Science and Analytical Services Division (project references JHI-C5-1, JHI-E1-1).

Keywords

  • Systematic literature review
  • Literature review
  • Agent-based modelling
  • Model design
  • Theory development
  • Cumulative science

Fingerprint

Dive into the research topics of 'How to conduct more systematic reviews of agent-based models and foster theory development: Taking stock and looking ahead'. Together they form a unique fingerprint.

Cite this